At
its most elemental level, the word “organic” means “alive.” The
following people, through their vision, sweat, passion and persistence,
brought life to the organics industry, propelling it into the $10.8
billion business it is today. Whether through farming, legislation,
innovation or education, these are individuals who have made it
possible for today’s generations to live a truly organic lifestyle.
They have dedicated their lives to improving ours, and they are alive
with the spirit of organics.
Roger Blobaum
President of Blobaum & Associates, a Washington, D.C.-based natural products consulting firm.
Years in the industry: 32. Blobaum began as an editorial
consultant to Rodale Press and spent six years on the organic steering
committee of the National Campaign for Sustainable Agriculture. He’s
been a board member of the International Organic Accreditation Service,
the Organic Farming Research Foundation, the Michael Fields
Agricultural Institute and the Organic Alliance.
How have you influenced the organics industry? “My attempts …
have focused on broadening the base of the organic community by
mobilizing support for organic food and farming by consumer,
environmental, animal protection and other public interest sectors. The
combination of organic farmers and the organic industry is still a tiny
economic sector, [which] needs allies to be effective in the political
and regulatory arenas, and lacks the resources and political clout to
go it alone.”
Do you think the mainstreaming of organics has been good for the industry?
“For the most part, [it’s] a necessary and positive development. This
seems obvious when the number of certified organic farmers, after 40
years of development, is still less than 9,000; only 0.3 percent of
U.S. crop and pasture land is under organic management; and organics
sales account for less than 1 percent of what consumers spend for food.
Mainstreaming will assure organic sector growth in the long run,
however, only if it can be accomplished without compromising organic
integrity, failing to meet consumer expectations, eroding public
confidence in the organic label, or making marketing claims that cannot
be verified.”
What do you think is the future of organic regulations?
“Overall, I believe [they] will become increasingly politicized and
globalized and that the influence of organic farmers, independent
organic companies, consumers, environmentalists and animal protection
advocates will be diminished. We see this already in the performance of
the National Organic Program, which is undermining public confidence in
the government-based regulatory/enforcement approach and is raising
serious concerns about the ability of government regulators to
guarantee organic integrity. Legislation to update and improve the 1990
Organic Foods Production Act would appear to be an obvious solution.
But this has been resisted due to mistrust of the political system that
would be called on to change the law. Trends [such as erosion of farmer
and consumer input and disappearance of pioneer organic companies
through mergers and acquisitions by international food companies] will
be exacerbated if the outdated and flawed organic law remains unchanged
and current attempts to weaken international organic norms and diminish
the influence of private certification and accreditation alternatives
continue.”
What do you think will be the next hot category in the organic marketplace?
Will any category or product fade? “If the growing trend toward
factory-farm practices on organic farms can be reversed, I believe the
marketing of organically produced meat, milk and other livestock
products is a huge, unrealized … opportunity.”
Bena Burda
Burda’s organic career began with Eden Foods in 1978. As the company’s
sales manager, she helped introduce the first certified organic soymilk
in the United States. Later, when she was sales manager for Bearito’s
Brand Organic Tortilla Chips, and the company began rotating organic
cotton with its corn crops, Burda began experimenting with the cotton.
In 1992 she and financial partner Jennifer Mueller co-founded Maggie’s
Organics, and in 1997 Burda bought out the company from Mueller to
create Maggie’s Organics/Clean Clothes.
Years in the industry: 26
Influence: “Katherine DiMatteo at the [Organic Trade
Association] has called me a ‘special pioneer.’ When things move easy,
I move on. … I kind of like to do hard stuff. I like to do new stuff.”
Burda adds, “I am not just into saving acres, I’m into empowering
workers.”
Mainstreaming: “I think it’s good and bad. It’s certainly what
we’ve dreamed and worked for for so long. … Accessibility is good, but
if it comes at the expense of our own specific interests? It has
watered down the integrity and quality of the industry.”
Future of organics regs: “I think it’s going to be convoluted
and very confusing. Especially as far as fibers, I think it will get
worse before it gets better. But it is that confusion that will bring
up new ideas.”
Hot category/fading category: Hot: socially responsible
products, like fair trade products. Fading: only those that don’t make
sense because of their packaging or marketing.
Amigo Cantisano and Kalita Todd
An organic farmer for more than 30 years, Cantisano stepped into the
industry in the early 1970s, when he set up a co-op and distribution
company. Since then, he has helped write the California Organic Food
Act of 1979 and helped found a sustainable agriculture program at the
University of California. He started an organics consulting business
and has worked continually as an activist for organics. He works with
Kalita Todd, his wife of 30 years, who declined to be interviewed,
saying she didn’t deserve the honor.
Years in the industry: 30 plus
Influence: “I’m a farming activist, trying to motivate and
stimulate people to get more involved. I got the first public money for
organic agriculture.”
Mainstreaming: “It’s a mixed bag. It brought attention to
quality farming. But on the negative side, some of the larger companies
have swallowed up smaller growers. Also, it has lost a little flavor,
since many of the people who were in it originally were into the
environmental and social sides, too.”
Future of organics regs: “I think the organic industry has to
become more vigilant … we need to participate. The government is so new
to this; they’re going to make mistakes. We need to educate them.”
Hot category/fading category: Hot: processed and ready-to-eat
foods, since they reach out to a large group of society. Fading:
Cantisano doesn’t foresee any category fading, noting that as more
young people can afford organics, they will be buying more.
Lynn Coody and Yvonne Frost
Founded Oregon Tilth in 1974.
Coody is currently policy director of the Organic Materials Review
Institute. She is chairwoman of the OTA accreditation subcommittee and
has worked internationally with the International Federation of Organic
Agriculture Movements. She also helped write OTA’s American Organic
Standards and has her own company, Organic Agsystems Consulting.
Recently Coody completed work on OTA’s newly revised fiber standards.
Frost began Simple Organic Solutions, a consulting business, in 2002,
and is still involved in the OTA. She was involved in passing the
original organic food law in Oregon.
Years in the industry: 30 years each
Influence: Coody: “My main influence is one of providing
infrastructure—providing organizational vision, standards writing,
manual writing—all stuff that you just have to sit in the chair and do.
I like to bring order to systems.”
Frost: “I’m just a pushy person, and I wanted to promote what is honest and aboveboard.”
Mainstreaming: Coody: “I can see two sides. I think it’s
wonderful that there are so many more organic acres. I’m also happy
there are more consumers interested in organics. But I also know, as a
farmer, it has created very difficult challenges for smaller farmers
and some of the original people in organics. But on the positive side
are the international contacts. It’s becoming a global community.”
Frost: “Mainstreaming has made people more aware of it. But … it’s
harder for the little guy to get in the business, and I think that’s
too bad … they’re depleting the humanity of the industry.”
Future of organics regs: Coody: “Creating a global international community through harmonized regulatory structures.”
Frost: “I hope money doesn’t buy a change. … We must as an industry
stay vigilant and make a stink [if organics regulations are
threatened].”
Hot category/fading category: Coody: Hot categories are organic
fiber and body care products. Frost: Hot categories include pet food,
health and beauty items, and natural and organic beef. Fading category:
Low-carb products and products made without attention to quality. “If
you have 10 companies that make the same damn thing, the quality will
end up selling the product.”
Michael Crooke
President and chief executive officer of Patagonia Inc., based in Ventura, Calif. Sales in 2002 were $220 million.
Years in the industry: 20 plus
Influence: Patagonia converted its entire sportswear line to 100
percent organically grown between 1994 and ’96. “Organic cotton was not
prevalent at the time, and the shift to organic required a company-wide
commitment—everyone from our designers to our catalog editors to our
retail store staff to our production team jumped in with both feet. We
launched a full-scale communications campaign to increase awareness of
organics among our employees and our customers. We took employees,
reporters, government officials and representatives from other
companies and environmental nonprofit organizations—more than 1,000
people in all—on tours of conventional and organic cotton farms to make
the argument for organics. … In the early days, we were the single
largest domestic buyer of organic cotton. We’re happy to say that this
is no longer the case. Larger players have entered the market, and we
take pride in having helped pave the way.”
Mainstreaming: “The increased popularity of organics among
mainstream consumers is a very positive development, in my opinion.
It’s in the best interest of the planet for organics to be mainstream
rather than niche or just ‘eco-groovy.’ … Mainstreaming organic cotton
has always been one of our goals. … We’re thrilled to see mainstream
players supporting organics. Higher, more predictable demand is good
for everyone involved.”
Future of organics regs: “It’s hard to predict the future, but I
can tell you what we’d like to see in the coming years. Introducing a
certification system for the post-harvest processing of organic fibers
would be a boon to the industry. It would help differentiate organic
suppliers and increase awareness of organics beyond foods. We’re also
supportive of expanding industry regulations to cover water use, soil
erosion and topsoil loss, and in-field labor standards. Transparency
and accountability are critical in order to maintain the current growth
trajectory.”
Hot category/fading category: “At Patagonia, we’re pretty
focused on the fiber business, so I’m probably biased when I say that I
think fibers are going to emerge as the hot category. And beyond
fibers, I anticipate significant growth across organic categories. This
is most definitely not a fad. Consumers have solid reasons to prefer
organics—from environmental preservation to human health to worker
safety to product quality. When you consider everything the organic
industry has going for it, it’s clear that the organic revolution has
just begun.”
Katherine DiMatteo
DiMatteo has been dedicated to organics since the late 1970s, when she
started working in and advocating natural food co-ops. She also served
as executive director of the Northeast Sustainable Energy Association
and as development director for the Peace Development Fund. She has
been executive director of the OTA since 1990.
Years in the industry: 25 plus
Influence: “I would have to say politics, policy and lobbying on behalf of standards.”
Mainstreaming: “It’s essential. Without organics moving from the
fringe or outside of the industry, we will never effect the change we
want in converting agriculture to be environmentally sound and reducing
negative impacts of nonorganic agriculture. If that’s what we’ve set
out to do—change the world—then we need to be mainstream. It comes with
risk and changes, but without it, we won’t achieve our mission.”
Future of organics regs: “I think the areas that have not been [regulated]. Improvements in standards and more harmonization in standards.”
Hot category/fading category: Hot: nonfood areas, like textile,
fashion, personal and body care products. Fading: Fresh fruits and
vegetables may be bypassed by other quickly growing sectors, like meats
and dairy.
Rep. Sam Farr
Democratic congressman from California.
Years in the industry: About 15. “In the late ’80s, I was in the [California] state assembly and the San Jose [Mercury News]
broke ‘the carrot caper’ story of a grower who was selling the same
crop as both organic and conventional. Shortly after that, I introduced
the California Organic Foods Act of 1990, and with the help of several
dedicated constituents, we got that legislation passed in a bipartisan
vote. I have been working to promote and protect the industry ever
since.”
Influence: “I am proud to say that COFA was used as the national
standard framework sponsored by Sen. Leahy of Vermont. … I was glad to
be part of the negotiations to stop GMOs, sludge and radiation in the
first proposed [NOP] rule, and be the lead sponsor to reinstate the
requirement” that livestock on certified organic farms eat organically
produced feed. “As a member of the House Agriculture Committee, I
was able to insert in the 1996 farm bill language for the first federal
organic-specific research at the [U.S. Department of
Agriculture/Agricultural Research Service]. Since moving to the House
Appropriations Committee, I have worked to increase federal
expenditures for organic and sustainable agriculture. … Currently, I am
working with the USDA on the organic assessment issue and [am] in
conversations regarding the recent directives issued—and then
rescinded—by the NOP.”
Mainstreaming: “That is a very complex question. Overall, I
would say it has [been a benefit]. Organics started as a lifestyle; the
industry has grown a lot as other agribusiness joined, and the [NOP]
rule provides enough flexibility to grow with it. I think providing
consumer confidence, accountability and increasing supply benefit all
those who use organic products and food.”
Future of organic regs: “We are still working with a fairly new
rule here, so we need to continue to work out the rough edges; this can
be done by improving NOP transparency and enforcement procedures. As
the USDA has found on several occasions, those in organic agriculture
are passionate about their issue. We all need to keep the pressure on
so we have a program that works for both growers and consumers.”
Hot category/fading category: “With meat scares, I think we will
continue to see strong increases in organic livestock. However, I think
the next long-term gainer will be in personal care products. People
want to know what they are putting on their bodies as much as they want
to know what they put in their bodies. I really don’t see any one
sector of organic agriculture slipping. What started out as a lifestyle
for a few is now snowballing into a choice for a large section of our
population.”
Jonathan and Katrina Frey
Jonathan Frey’s parents began growing cabernet sauvignon and gray
Riesling grapes on their ranch in Mendocino County, Calif., in the late
1960s. After one of the wines won an award, Jonathan and his brother
Matthew founded Frey Vineyards. Today, most of Jonathan’s 11 siblings
and their spouses work the vineyard, which produces 19 different
vintages and shipped 62,000 cases of wine last year.
Years in the industry: 24
Influence: “We’re pioneers in organic wine, with the oldest and
largest [American organic] vineyard,” says. Katrina Frey, Jonathan’s
wife. Frey Vineyards is also certified by the international biodynamic
organization Demeter. “Demeter is seen as the gold standard in the
organics industry,” she says. “We’re the first vineyard in the U.S. to
use the word biodynamic and Demeter-certified on our wine labels.”
Mainstreaming: “I’m concerned with the potential for dilution
and integration of organic standards, but I do think mainstreaming has
increased the market for organics.”
Future of organic regs: “I think we’ve got the fox guarding the
henhouse. We’re really active in the GMO-free zone in Mendocino County,
and the USDA is trying to pick that apart.”
Hot category: “Maybe clothing. I think we’ve just scratched the surface of that.”
Drew and Myra Goodman
In 1984, Drew and Myra Goodman founded Earthbound Farm, the first
company to successfully launch prewashed, packaged salads for retail
sale. Today the company has become one of the largest growers and
shippers of organic produce in North America. The Goodmans collaborated
on their responses to the following questions.
Years in the industry: 20
Influence: “Earthbound Farm has proven that organic farming is
viable on a large scale. In the retail arena, we’ve shown that organic
produce can be profitable for retailers of all sizes. And from the
consumer’s perspective, we’ve been successful in maintaining a
reasonable price premium for organics.”
Mainstreaming: “There are so many facets to this answer, but we
think it’s true that a rising tide lifts all boats. Since organic
produce is a ‘gateway’ category, consumers usually branch out from
there to wanting other organic items. It’s a spiral that just keeps
climbing.”
Future of organics regs: “It’s important to protect the purity
and integrity of the regulations that govern organic production. We saw
earlier this year that people inside the USDA thought they could modify
a few rules and weaken the standards without even going in front of the
National Organic Standards Board. What this whole episode illustrates
is that we have to continue to be vigilant about organic standards.”
Hot category/fading category: “Organic convenience foods and
snacks are growing at an impressive rate right now, but that’s not
surprising. Everyone’s looking for products that are more convenient as
well as healthier. But there are also some areas where organic hasn’t
even scratched the surface—for example, fast casual and quick-serve
restaurants.”
Lewis Grant
Grant was farming sustainably before organics gained popularity in the
1970s. Since 1975, when he and his son, Andy, began phasing Grant
Family Farms into a completely organic operation, the farm has become
the largest privately run organic vegetable farm in the United States.
Years in the industry: 30 plus
Influence: “I have been very active in the industry nationally,
serving two terms on the board of the OFRF and on a research committee.
But some ways [I’ve influenced the industry] are intangible. An awful
lot of our neighbors are now using organic farming techniques. I’ve had
an influence on how our neighbors are farming.”
Mainstreaming: “Obviously I think that’s important because
that’s what we’re into. … There is some division in organics between
very small operations and larger operations, but we fully respect and
cooperate with the small operators.”
Future of organics regs: “Since the federal organic law was
passed in 1990 and took until 2003 to be implemented, I think
gradualism will define it. There will constantly be challenges to it,
but due to the large response [the organic rule] got from the public, I
feel it has pretty stable support.”
Hot category/fading category: “The organics industry is not
really a popularity contest between different products. The one big gap
was in the meat industry, but that has been resolved.”
Gary Hirshberg
President and chief executive officer of Stonyfield Farm, one of the
leading manufacturers of all-natural and organic yogurt in the United
States. Hirshberg is also founder and chairman of O’Naturals, a new
chain of natural fast-food restaurants.
Years in the industry: 22
Influence: “When we first began to produce organic yogurt in
1995, people thought we were crazy because of the high cost of
ingredients. Many said we couldn’t produce organic foods on such a
large scale and still remain profitable, while others claimed the
demand for organic simply wasn’t there.
“But over the past 10 years we’ve made the transition from a small
natural foods company to now being the nation’s No. 1-selling yogurt in
natural foods [according to market research company SPINS] and the No.
3 yogurt in the grocery channel.”
Mainstreaming: “Humans have done an enormous amount of damage to
this planet, and our generation of business leaders has no choice but
to reverse these impacts if the earth is to remain habitable. So, yes,
the mainstreaming of organics is not only good for the industry but
necessary for the earth. Greater demand for organic foods leads to more
certified organic family farms, less toxic chemicals and pesticides,
and a healthier planet for our children.”
Future of organics regs: “With the implementation of new USDA
organic rules in 2002, people became more aware of organics, and they
also felt more secure due to consistent organic food standards. But we
must remain vigilant, and stand up to the special interests, if we are
to maintain the integrity of the organic industry.”
Hot category/fading category: “Consumers are looking for
nutritious, organic foods that fit into their active lifestyles, so
we’re seeing more ‘grab ’n go’ offerings every year.”
Barclay Hope
President of Albert’s Organics, a division of United Natural Foods Inc.
Albert’s was the first certified organic distributor with national
coverage. It distributes 250 varieties of fruits and vegetables to
5,000 natural foods stores, supermarkets and restaurants in the United
States and Canada.
Years in the industry: 27—“my entire adult life.” Hope began as
a driver for Sunburst Farms and became a store manager in 1979. In
1981, he opened Hope ’n Hagen’s Markets in Goleta and Ventura, Calif.,
and in 1988, he launched Buonapasta, a Santa Barbara, Calif.-based
pasta and sauce manufacturer. He became a Wild Oats store manager in
1995 and joined Albert’s Organics as Western division general manager
in 1997. In 2001, he was named Albert’s president.
Influence: “One of the driving philosophies of my personal and
professional endeavors is that I want to see as much acreage
transitioned over to organic farming methods, and organic product use
becoming an everyday part of people’s eating habits. At every stop
along my career path, I have conveyed this to employees and as a part
of my marketing message. Hopefully, I have had some impact along the
way. Albert Lusk, the founder of the company I now run, was a visionary
whose dedication to the industry and belief in its eventual growth was
a big influence on me and on the industry as a whole.”
Mainstreaming: “It is gratifying to see more and more organic
products available and the acceptance of the mainstream consumer
continuing to grow. As an industry, however, we need to stay vigilant
to potential threats to our integrity and core values as the industry
continues to move towards commoditization.”
Future of organics regs: “Despite its rocky first attempt at
implementation, the subsequent, adopted regulations have helped to
legitimize our movement in the eyes of the mainstream consumer and
helped to achieve some standardization across many governing bodies,
which will benefit the industry [in the] long term. We must be vigilant
at safeguarding the integrity of the current standards so that
‘backdoor’ legislation, as recently witnessed with an attempt to water
down poultry standards, does not degrade the high standards that many
dedicated people worked so hard to establish and maintain over the
years.”
Hot category/fading category: “Organic meat, given recent
exposures of the questionable practices on the conventional side [that]
have given us mad cow issues. This category will have the
highest-percentage growth in the next few years. I also think that
value-added organic produce and meat products [that appeal] to the time
constraints of today’s consumer will be big. I think the low-carb craze
will fade dramatically.”
Eckhart Kiesel
Kiesel began working for Rapunzel Naturkost in Germany in 1990 as
director for overseas organic agricultural projects. In 1997, he helped
establish Rapunzel Pure Organics and became president of the company in
2001.
Years in the industry: 14
Influence: “Growing and manufacturing organic food and spreading
its distribution is only part of my ideal. I think that organic
agriculture without fair trade, and without observing social issues for
the organic farmers and workers in the developing world—and also here
in the ‘northern countries’—doesn’t make sense. By developing fair
trade standards and applying them to Rapunzel’s organic product
imports, I hope to have made some changes in this respect.”
Mainstreaming: “Yes and no. Yes, in terms of getting it out to
the public and opening awareness for more people and products. No, in
the way that the organic industry, which started as an alternative
think tank with goals that were quite different from the mainstream
industry, is in danger of getting absorbed by bigger corporate
structures and their way of dealing with people, companies and
products.”
Future of organics regs: “If our organic industry and the public
keep their eyes and ears open as we’ve done in the past, I believe we
can maintain and improve the organic standards. But if policy and money
starts to play a role in adapting or reviewing the standards and we
don’t watch out, then we will face serious backlashes. I hope that
internationally, all organic standards will be harmonized soon.”
Hot category/fading category: “I think organic beer and wine
will come out big. I hope that highly processed items and white
sugar/white flour products will fade.”
Sen. Patrick Leahy
Leahy, D-Vt., is known as the “father” of the organic standards and
labeling program. In 1989, he authored the legislation that chartered
the organics program in 1990, and he continues to be one of the
strongest proponents for organics in Congress.
Years in the industry: 15
Influence: “When I became chairman of the Agriculture Committee
I made it a priority to help give the emerging organic industry a solid
footing for growth, and I wrote the Organic Foods Production Act to
accomplish that. There were bumps along the way, but our efforts
finally succeeded with the USDA’s development and adoption of the final
certification rule and the launch of the labeling program.”
Mainstreaming: “The organics industry has evolved across the
spectrum from ‘crunchy’ to corporate and everything in between, while
still basically maintaining the grassroots idealism that it started
with. Certified organics give consumers the power, through their buying
decisions, to help decide how our food is grown and how our environment
is treated. Buying organic also helps to strengthen our rural
communities and family farmers. We all benefit when the organic
industry thrives.”
Future of organics regs: “Organics are an especially bright
sector in American agriculture, and we are poised to stay on that
trajectory. Organics have grown dramatically in breadth and depth, at a
rate of about 20 percent a year over the last decade. That’s because
when American consumers see the new USDA organic label, they know that
it’s backed by a strong rule, and that the organic label means what it
says. Our challenge, as the certification program moves beyond its
infancy, is to keep it that way.”
Eldon, Wendell, Harlan and Homer Lundberg
Lundberg Family Farms, founded by Albert and Frances Lundberg in 1937,
was an early pioneer of organic rice growing in America. Their sons,
Eldon, Wendell, Harlan and Homer, continued that family tradition,
beginning in the late 1960s, and began selling their organic rice
directly to the public, rather than to wholesalers who might commingle
it with rice grown by conventional methods. Homer spoke for all four
sons when answering NFM’s questions.
Years in the industry: about 35
Influence: The Lundberg influence on organics predates the
flourishing of the industry. More than 65 years ago, Albert Lundberg
started farming in northern California, determined to improve the soil
and the environment. This was at a time when mining the soil was the
standard procedure. With his Ph.D. in common sense, he simply applied
nature-friendly techniques to his farming operation—techniques that the
brothers continue today. Rotating crops, enriching crops, incorporating
straw and stubble, and encouraging wildlife are all foundations of
organic farming that were mainstays of the Lundberg operation long
before organic farming became cool.
Mainstreaming: “If the industry is to grow, the products must be
presented to as many people as possible. However, we must continue to
lean toward the people who are really dedicated to the industry, and
pass by the faddists and quick-buck artists.”
Future of organics regs: “We hope organic regulations will be
tailored by the people with experience in each separate area. It would
be tragic if the laws are based on wishful thinking and individual
social values, no matter how well meaning they may be.”
Hot category/fading category: “We do not focus on hot categories
or fads. We are only interested in products that will endure the test
of time. Good health is a long-term project.”
Marty Mesh
Serves on the boards of the OTA and the Southern Sustainable
Agriculture Working Group. He is a founding member of OMRI, started
Florida Certified Organic Growers and Consumers, and heads Quality
Certification Services. Through his work with the Florida International
Volunteer Corps, he has helped farm workers in developing countries.
Years in the industry: 31
Influence: Mesh says he has been “a voice for smaller-scale and
family farms in the industry, so agribusiness does not roll over them.”
He also sees his role as helping midscale and small producers gain
market access. “I also try to get more resources available, like
federal money for organic research.”
Mainstreaming: “The environmental benefits of certified organic
farming on hundreds of acres are tremendous for everybody, the animals,
the environment and our water. But one of the things we need to do as
an industry is figure out how smaller-scale farms will have a place in
the market.”
Future of organics regs: “Social accountability. Under the
[NOP], social justice was not under the standards.” He also foresees
voluntary labeling as a marketing option. “I think our goal as an
industry is to keep consumer confidence. We need to work together.”
Hot category/fading category: Hot: organic fiber, raw foods and
certified organic aquaculture. Fading: “I’m an eternal optimist. It’s
just a matter of educating consumers.”
Nell Newman
Co-founder, with Peter Meehan, of Aptos, Calif.-based Newman’s Own
Organics, which was established in 1993 as a division of Newman’s Own,
and became a separate company in 2001. Products, which are certified
organic, include pretzels, cookies and popcorn.
Years in the industry: 12
Influence: “Before we even started the company, we had to
convince my father [actor and Newman’s Own founder Paul Newman] that
organics tasted good, not like the hippie food my mother used to make
in the ’60s. Our motto became ‘Great tasting products that happen to be
organic.’ Our pretzels were not nine-grain because that wouldn’t look
or taste like a pretzel to Pop. What we wanted to do is convince
people, like Pop, to try organics by making the kind of familiar
products that he enjoys and we loved as kids.”
Mainstreaming: “The mainstreaming of organics into supermarkets
has been a great step in introducing these products to people who might
not normally encounter them, as they may not have natural foods stores
close by. We think consumers really want to know more about what they
are eating and its source. Once they see the benefits of organic
products, the more likely they are to buy them.”
Future of organics regs: “Hopefully, [they] will be more progressive and less confrontational under a new administration.”
Hot category/fading category: “It’d be nice if the next hot
category will be high carb, and the products to fade will be low carb.
Seriously, though, we know that all snack foods should be enjoyed in
moderation. We are currently expanding into dried fruit and salad
greens, which are all organic, of course. The trend we’d really like to
see continue is the rapid growth in organic products [that] support
sustainable agriculture.”
Steve Pavich
Former partner in Pavich Family Farms, once the world’s largest
producer of certified organic table grapes. He now owns Pavich
Agricultural Consulting in Phoenix.
Years in the industry: 33
Influence: “We’ve always been 100 percent dedicated to organic. We’ve tried to be leaders by example.”
Mainstreaming: “Yes and no. From the ‘yes’ standpoint, there’s
more volume of products to more people. We were one of the first to
make the transition into the mass market in the mid-’80s and we had
huge battles with chain stores that wouldn’t embrace organics. From the
‘no’ standpoint, the original curators of the organic movement have
either been compromised or pushed out because of competition. Growers
don’t have the freedom of speech to challenge stores—[retailers] are
almost like a feudal empire. The solution is still empowerment by the
consumer, demanding stores tell the truth about whether they’re really
supporting small farmers.”
Future of organics regs: “Enforcement is going to be a continual
problem. Will we get an evil empire group of major food companies that
will change the laws?” Also, Pavich believes, “a few years down the
road, biotech companies are going to screw up—it’s just a matter of
time when we wake up and find one of these supposed benign genes aren’t
benign. [Genetic modification] is going to blow up. [Therefore], it’s a
matter of national security that organic is kept organic. And organics
will get new meaning and will get the true respect it deserves from the
scientific community.”
Hot category: “Functional foods and food as medicine, but it’s
an educational process. The real growth in the industry is on the
processed food side, and that’s a little bit disappointing to me.”
Anthony Rodale
Chairman of The Rodale Institute, which works worldwide to promote a
regenerative food system that improves the environment and human
health.
Years in the industry: “Professionally, 15 years, but I was born
into an organic family. As a young child in the mid-’60s, I heard the
word organic before it was really cool or mainstream.”
Influence: “I helped to bring the Institute [which his
grandfather conceptualized and his father founded] forward, continuing
to develop science and research and helping to grow and expand farmer
outreach and youth education.”
Mainstreaming: “Yes, because that’s what it’s all about—organics
was intended to really influence and change all agriculture. What the
organic pioneers and the public wanted needs to continue to happen on a
local, national and international level, because we’re now living in a
global system.”
Future of organics regs: “They need to be continually upheld to
the highest level of accountability. They need to be
transparent—through the USDA, nonprofits and the general public working
together and not being co-opted by any one industry. Internationally,
we need to improve harmonization, collaboration and communication
through a network of [world organic] leaders. In the long term,
everyone is going to have to work together because we’re eating food
from around the world. We need [organic standard] equivalency on some
level.”
Hot category/fading category: “There are two hot
categories—fiber and the energy industry. But anything that has
associated itself with a current diet trend—anything with ‘low’ in the
name—doesn’t have a long life.”
Craig Sams
Chairman of U.K.-based certifier the Soil Association, a 58-year-old
agency that also offers support to organic farmers across the United
Kingdom.
Years in the industry: 37. Sams ran a macrobiotic restaurant in
the United Kingdom with his brother Gregory from 1967-73, and in 1969
opened a natural foods store. He launched a whole-grain bakery in 1972,
became a large-scale manufacturer of peanut butter and, in 1977,
developed fruit juice-sweetened jams under the Whole Earth brand. In
1991, he founded Green & Black’s organic chocolate company. He’s
the author of About Macrobiotics (Athene Publishing Co., 1972), and The
Little Food Book, to be published in the United States this month.
Influence: “[I] opened the first natural foods store in Europe,
then began wholesaling to the United Kingdom and European retailers. We
developed the first European sources of organic brown rice in 1970 …
and the first fruit juice-sweetened jams. About Macrobiotics was
translated into six European languages and sold several hundred
thousand copies, helping to define the dietary choices of the
foundation generation of organic consumers. Green & Black’s
chocolate, now the world’s leading organic chocolate brand … showed
that you could offer the highest-quality product range, competitively
priced and aggressively marketed, without compromising on organic
values. It was the first fair trademarked brand in the United Kingdom.
It has helped define and drive the organic movement.”
Mainstreaming: “Ultimately, organics is about the consumer and
the producer—processors and retailers are facilitators. Going
mainstream means more consumers can access organic food whenever they
want, and more producers can convert to organic standards. There has
been some dumbing down of the broader nutritional message of which
organics is a part, and a lot of the first-generation mainstream
products have just been cleaned-up versions of junk food.”
Future of organics regs: “It’s a great shame that, with 10 years
to collaborate and coordinate, the European Union and the U.S. organic
stakeholders and IFOAM weren’t competent to develop organic regulations
that were equivalent. This would have been the strongest worldwide
protection against dilution of standards. But I still think that the
general direction of regulations will be towards greater quality—that’s
what drives the organic market.”
Hot category/fading category: Hot: whole grains and vegetables.
Fading: “Nightshades will receive a lot more attention and people will
treat potatoes, tomatoes, peppers and eggplant with the same restraint
already accorded to that other popular nightshade, tobacco. So a
decline in tomato products and of products high in refined flour and
sugar is likely. Functional foods will never really get beyond yogurt
derivatives. People will balance their own diets, not leave it to food
technologists.”
Bob Scaman
President and founder of Goodness Greeness, an organics distributor in the Chicago, Detroit and Milwaukee areas.
Years in the industry: 14
Influence: “When we started, Chicago didn’t have an organics distributor. We maintain organics continuity in the Midwest.”
Mainstreaming: “Absolutely. In our market in particular, we
don’t have a strong natural foods presence—not like the Rockies and the
West and East coasts have. We made the product available to consumers
who wanted it, and now you see [organics in the Midwest] in Wal-Mart,
Safeway, Jewel. The preponderance of product legitimizes the
value-added perception to the consumer, especially in this part of the
country where there aren’t a lot of health food stores and pill shops.”
Future of organics regs: “I think we’ll continue the cycle of
the USDA trying to dumb down the regulations and the OTA going back and
fighting. The OTA is well organized for the fight.”
Hot category: “Flowers. I think they’re the last bastion of what
hasn’t been done in organics. There’s nothing like going to the
farmer’s market and buying that perfect bouquet.”
Years in the industry: 25. Scowcroft began as a national
organizer working on pesticide policy and organic issues for Friends of
the Earth, became the first full-time director of California Certified
Organic Farmers, and then co-founded OFRF.
Influence: “Certainly through my legislative work with each
nonprofit organization. I think my work with the media, as a
spokesperson for organic farmers and as an organizer, has contributed
to the expansion of the industry. I seem to have the knack of making
connections and introducing people to each other that would not
normally see the common ground they might share if they worked
together.”
Mainstreaming: “Overall, it is the only way to go. Most people
got into this movement and/or industry to expand the offerings of
organically labeled products to all corners of the food system. In a
way, though, events unfolded so fast and the industry changed so fast
we still haven’t had the opportunity to conduct a vision-impact report
to see if this is where we want to be and, by extension, to plan for
where we want to go next.”
Future of organics regs: “I think that as long as there are
people who conduct fraud out there we will have regulations and the
laws needed to enforce them. Obviously, we will need dedicated
government stewards who can work with the public sector in partnership,
which we don’t seem to have now in at least one agency. However, we do
have them in several others, and it gives hope to those of us in it for
the duration that this situation can be turned around too.”
Hot category: “Meat products will expand exponentially, and that
in return will impact organic feed producers. I also think cotton will
experience a bit of a revival, although that may come from overseas.”
George Siemon
CEO and founding farmer of Organic Valley Family of Farms, a
16-year-old cooperative of 619 small farms across the United States.
Years in the industry: 28
Influence: “Over the years I’ve had the privilege of serving in
a number of capacities—including chairman of the National Organic
Standard Board Livestock Committee and the OTA’s Livestock
Committee—where I was able to advance the voice of the farmer. Through
my work at Organic Valley, I’ve been able to develop a model for
self-determined, stable and sustainable farmer price. As a result, our
farmers in many cases are being paid double the price paid their
conventional counterparts. This year we stand to be at the $200 million
mark—higher sales than we ever imagined! I’ve also been able to create
a supply-management model for farmers, a tool that is crucial in
organics. The co-op tries not to produce any more than we can sell,
because we’re trying to pay farmers a sustainable price.”
Mainstreaming: “Yes. It has expanded our circle, our sphere of
influence, and brought greater appreciation for the vision that is at
the heart of organic agriculture. Today there is virtually no food
category that doesn’t provide an organic choice. The challenge we face
now is to educate consumers to reach for more meaning in their food
purchases by supporting family farms, local supply and cooperative
business models. I’m encouraged by what I see, however. Efforts to
heighten awareness are taking hold in numerous regions across the
country.”
Future of organics regs: “The NOP rules are the most stringent
in the world, but they require constant effort to maintain and improve.
I believe we will open up the originating law to correct some of the
foundation issues. This will be a grave time, however. It will be
critical for us to make sure that the standards are not weakened by
special interests that are not friendly to organics.”
Hot category/fading category: “Organic meat may not be the next
hot category, but it is so undeveloped and has so much growth potential
that it is sure to be the biggest growth sector for the next few years.
I believe that the low-carb category will fade.”
Michael Sligh
Program director for the Rural Advancement Foundation
International-USA, a nonprofit group that promotes sustainable and
organic farming education and research, and monitors biotechnology.
Sligh was a charter member and founding chairman of the NOSB, and
helped develop, promote and defend the Farm Credit Act, the Sustainable
Agriculture Research and Education program and the Organic Foods
Production Act of 1990. He is accreditation chairman for the
International Organic Accreditation Service.
Years in the industry: 36. “I come from a long line of family
farmers, and I started my first intentionally organic garden patch in
1969 and helped to start a local natural foods cooperative out of our
garage.” Sligh farmed organic grain, vegetables and fruits throughout
the 1970s and, as a trained anthropologist, directed sustainable and
organic agriculture projects in the Caribbean in the early 1980s. He
joined RAFI-USA in 1984.
Influence: “My influence has primarily come through our work on
the development of federal, international and private-sector policies,
regulations and marketing strategies to promote sustainable and organic
farming and marketing.” Recently, Sligh wrote Who Owns Organic—The
Global Status, Prospects and Challenges of a Changing Organic Market.
Mainstreaming: “Overall, of course we are all thrilled and
gratified at the global growth and continued steady adoption of organic
agricultural practices and the many successes in the marketplace.”
However, he says, “Mainstream success should not be measured simply by
sales and acres figures. Success must also include ensuring continued,
fair access to the market for our farmers, fair return on investment
and labor for farmers and farm workers, and fair contracts with the
buyers, and it should continue to encourage new entrants into organic
without undermining the early adopters.”
Future of organics regs: Sligh believes the industry should
honestly evaluate and reflect on the lessons from the last 15 years and
then make reforms that protect gains but realign the balance of power
and responsibilities. “There are many more things that government can
do to help the organics industry, like much more research and
education, but we may have also asked for too much in other areas like
accreditation and standards setting. We should watch and learn from our
European partners as they attempt to define the future of organics for
Europe. We need to do the same by asking, ‘What do we want organics in
the U.S. to look like in 10 years? And what policies, regulations and
activities are best suited to get us there?’”
Hot category: Sligh hopes to see growth in the use of combination claims, such as “certified organic and fair trade.”
Zea Sonnabend
Eco-Farm conference coordinator for the Ecological Farming Association;
processor, farm inspector and member of the certification committee for
CCOF.
Years in industry: 25. Sonnabend started out as an organic
gardening teacher, and began farming organic prunes, figs and peaches
in California in 1982. She sold the farm in 1989 and went to work for
YOCAL, an organic farmers marketing cooperative. She has been with CCOF
since 1982 and Eco-Farm since 1993, and was a member of the NOSB from
1993-96.
Influence: “I’ve kept the snake-oil salesmen at bay,” she jokes.
“I’ve worked on using a rational, scientific basis to develop what
fertilizers and pesticide controls are OK, and I’ve also participated
in educational efforts to get more farmers to use organic methods.”
Mainstreaming: “It’s an oversimplified question. Has it been
good for everyone in the organic community as a whole? My position is
yes—having less pesticides used on less land can only be good in the
end.”
Future of organics regs: “Unfortunately, I think they’re here to
stay. Those of us in from the beginning have quite a bit of regret
[that] we instituted a nightmare to watchdog very naïve regulations
from special interests trying to control them.”
Hot category: Prunes.
Natural Foods Merchandiser volume XXV/number 10/p. 74, 76-78, 80, 82, 84, 86, 88, 90 |