September 16, 2003 14:24:56

• Section Front

E-mail This Story  Printable Version

WTO Tries To Pick Up The Pieces

CANCUN, Mexico, Sept. 16, 2003



 (Photo: AP)



"We want the opportunity to compete freely."
Brazil President
Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva



(AP) World Trade Organization leaders, crippled by two major defeats in four years, are searching for a way to win back the trust of poor nations and cobble together a global trade treaty that will shape the world's economy for years to come.

Developing countries say they won't take any more bullying from the rich, and want a deal that will help even the poorest.

The demands came amid the surprise collapse of crucial trade negotiations in this Mexican resort. Just as ministers were digging in for an extra day of talks, the meeting's chairman, Mexican Foreign Secretary Luis Ernesto Derbez, called off negotiations, saying there wasn't enough agreement to move forward.

Developing nations — some triumphantly — leaked the news to journalists in the hallways of Cancun's convention center, even as U.S. trade officials gave a news conference explaining how negotiators were trying to move forward.

"Unless they listen to countries, unless they listen to the problems we have in meeting some of the demands of the developing countries, this is what will happen," said Rafidah Aziz, Malaysia's minister for international trade and investment.

In Washington, Bush administration officials expressed disappointment late Monday over the failure of the talks, but they refused to speculate whether the 2006 deadline for completing negotiations would be met.

The failure of talks will be felt around the world. Rice farmers in Asia and wheat farmers in Kansas were preparing for a decision in Cancun that would have led to the reduction of agricultural subsidies and tariffs.

Some farmers could have been forced out of business, while others — from poor producers in Africa to large multinationals in the United States — would have found new markets.

For consumers, the prices on many products would have fallen, unhindered by import tariffs, while other basic food supplies may have become more expensive without the help of subsidies.

Still, during five days of talks in Cancun, ministers spent little time on what was expected to be the main issue: agriculture.

Instead, they argued over whether to launch formal negotiations on several new topics, including rules on foreign investment and competition. Several nations insisted on taking up the talks, while other developing nations refused.

The failure of the talks makes it nearly impossible for the WTO to reach its main goal: a new global trade treaty by the end of the next year.

U.S. officials argued the treaty would have jump-started a sluggish world economy, and U.S. Trade Representative Robert Zoellick accused some countries of "tactics of inflexibility and inflammatory rhetoric."

"A number of countries just thought it was a freebie — they could just make whatever points they suggested, argue, and not offer and give," he said. "And now they're going to face the cold reality of that strategy, coming home with nothing."

He listed countries — like China, Uruguay, Sri Lanka and Panama — that had supported negotiations. And, in an indication that those who stood up to the world's most powerful economy will also be shut out of it, he said U.S. trade officials will pursue negotiations on several bilateral and regional free trade agreements.

The United States is pushing for a free trade agreement that would stretch from Canada to Chile, but the talks in Cancun appeared to have called that into question, also.

Brazil led a bloc of nations that stood up to the United States and Europe in Cancun, and it could do the same during negotiations for a free trade agreement of the Americas later this year in Miami.

In Rio de Janeiro, Brazil President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva expressed disappointment Monday over the failure of the talks but said it represented a victory for the developing world, which demanded a level playing field.

"We didn't ask for any benefits, privileges or favors, what we are asking is that we are treated equally by the developing countries that want foreign trade," Silva said. "We want the opportunity to compete freely."

Silva said Brazil, one of the world's largest agricultural producers, was looking to open up trade opportunities with countries in Africa and the Middle East.

Analysts say Brazil wants to expand trade links with other countries to gain better leverage in the proposed Free Trade Area of the Americas, which seeks to create a hemisphere-wide trade bloc by 2005.

The international aid group Oxfam, which worked closely with developing nations, said the meeting was a lesson for the United States and Europe.

"They can't come to WTO conferences anymore and behave like this," spokesman Sam Barratt said.

Thousands of protesters, many of them farmers who would have been hurt by new trade rules, marched on the meeting and tried to shut it down. They were part of a growing protest movement that gained international fame in 1999 in Seattle, the WTO's last major setback.

WTO Director-General Supachai Panitchpakdi said diplomats would meet in December in Geneva to decide how to proceed, adding the WTO cannot allow talks to be derailed.

"I'm quite disappointed with the way we have to conclude this meeting this way," he said late Sunday in Cancun. "But I'm not discouraged."

U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan said he was disappointed at the collapse of the Cancun talks but expressed hope that all sides would return to negotiations.

"Not much was achieved, but I hope that is not the end of the road and that the parties will go back, and reflect, and then come back in a determined fashion to try and fashion an agreement within the next year or so," Annan said upon arriving at U.N. headquarters.

He noted that "for the first time the developing countries have found their collective voice in international trade negotiations and acted in concern to defend their interests," U.N. spokesman Fred Eckhard said.

Many wondered how the WTO would proceed when there were such obvious gaps, both between the organization's 146 members and public opinion.

EU Trade Commissioner Pascal Lamy acknowledged globalization was not an easy sell.

"The benefits of trade opening are spread over millions of people who don't know it," he said. "The costs of trade opening are concentrated over a few constituencies who have a lot of complaining capacity."

By Traci Carl
©MMIII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.





Back to Top Back To Top


Help  • Advertise  • Feedback  • Terms of Service  • Privacy  • CBS News Bios
©MMIII, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.


• Interactives
• Iraq: After Saddam
• War On Terror
• Diplomatic Dispatches
New World Disorder
Waging their war on economic globalization with firebombs, sticks and rocks, some 5,000 protesters clash with police at the IMF and World Bank summit in Prague.

Mexico
Learn about the people, economy and history.

 Video

CBS News Analyst Pamela Falk discussees the World Trade Organization's failure in Mexico with CBS News Correspondent Melissa McDermott.

 Story

WTO Trade Talks Collapse
 Story

Poor Nations Air Subsidies Gripe
 Story

Tight Security As WTO Meets
 Story

Global Economy Seen Improving
 Story

Cheap Drugs For Third-World OK'd
 Story

EU Won't Budge On Biotech Rules
 Story

WTO: U.S. Trade Rules Illegal
 Story

EU & U.S. Shake Hands, Wag Fingers
 Story

Europe Takes Bite At Bush
 Story

Clash Of The Economic Titans







All Broadcasts
The Early Show 
CBS Evening News 
48 Hours 
60 Minutes 
60 Minutes II 
The Sat. Early Show 
Sunday Morning 
Face The Nation 
CBS Morning News 
Up To The Minute 
close [x]